Marching With Germans

By Joe Mathews

Journalist and Irvine senior fellow at the New America Foundation. He is co-author of California Crackup: How Reform Broke the Golden State and How We Can Fix It (UC Press, 2010).

Fri, July 30th, 2010

I've spent the past two days in Northern California playing host to a group of two dozen foreign scholars and practitioners. They are early arrivals to a free, public event that starts Friday night in San Francisco, the 2010 Global Forum on Modern Direct Democracy. (Full disclosure: I'm co-president of the event with a Swiss-Swede journalist named Bruno. Long story).

Listening to the Germans in the group is a trip. Initiative and referendum - previously discredited because of the Nazis' use of the plebiscite - have made a comeback in Germany since the end of the Cold War. Now, all 16 German states have popular initiative and referendum.

There is even talk of establishing the process on the federal level.

What's trippy is the politics. When it comes to initiative and referendum, the debate in Germany is a mirror image of California. While the initiative process is broadly popular in California, liberals here tend to express the most doubts and strongest skepticism about initiatives; those on the right are quicker to embrace the process. In Germany, Greens and Social Democrats - many of them more liberal than U.S. Democrats - are embracing direct democracy as a way around political elites they see as resistant to change. It is the Germany's conservatives who are resisting direct democracy.

What explains this? Distrust of government. The American right, having developed a critique of government as the enemy, sees the initiative process as a tool to fight back. The European left offers a related critique: They see threats in big things - international corporations and big transnational governing institutions - that seem beyond the reach of democracy and the judgment of ordinary people. Thus, they see direct democracy as a counterweight to such institutions. And so they have embraced it, not only in Germany but also across the continent.

So if you join us in San Francisco this weekend, you may see something strange: lots of agreement between American conservatives and European liberals, at least when the subject is direct democracy.

Bookmark/Search this post with:

Referenda in Germany

Submitted by Graham (in Germany) (not verified) on Mon, 08/02/2010 - 15:30.

The referendum may be theoretically possible in Germany, but I've lived here for 15 years and have not experienced one yet. Even though a large proportion of the population thought that we should have one on the introduction of the Euro, or the ratification of the EU constitution, in both cases the national government took the decision without consulting its citizens in that way.

Your perceptions makes the case too easy , Joe

Submitted by andi gross (not verified) on Sun, 08/01/2010 - 15:01.

Joe likes to make it easy. But life is more complecated. In Germany as well as in California. One of the most conservative german state, the Bavarians, are today very much backing I&R, while there are many greens and socialdemocrats who think the cause of the people is too important to leave it to the people, the classical elitest arrogance. In California too I know liberals who support I%R because they know that money and organised spcial interests controle Sacramento even more than the ballot boxes. Character and your view of politics as well as human beeings, your philosophy, matters more than party affiliations; So please, Joe, dont make it simple, make it in a way, that we can learn , why democrats need it and how we can improve it, that all democrats can identify with it ! Thanks. andi gross

Please note, statements and opinions expressed on the Fox&Hounds Blog are solely those of their respective authors and may not represent the views of Fox&Hounds Daily or its employees thereof. Fox&Hounds Daily is not responsible for the accuracy of any of the information supplied by the site's bloggers.