Lights, Camera, Inaction

David Crane
Lecturer and Research Scholar at Stanford University and President of Govern for California

Some politicians must think Californians are fools. Either that or they
must believe the Titanic wouldn’t have sunk had just the tip of the
iceberg been removed while the rest of it stayed hidden below the

The politicians I’m referring to are those engaged in vigorous
grandstanding about the city of Bell’s compensation abuses.

So far
we’ve heard calls to publish every government employee salary and to
make Bell give its citizens refunds. But we haven’t heard anything that
would actually make a difference in solving our state’s financial woes.

While government can and should make public every employee’s salary and
benefits, that will do nothing to change exploding employment costs. In
fact, politicians could get rid of every "spiked" government salary in
California right now and still not make a real dent in government

Spiked salaries didn’t force Oakland to lay off police
officers, Vallejo to enter bankruptcy, San Francisco to cut public
defender budgets, Los Angeles to face a future in which a third of its
revenues is dedicated to retirement costs, or the state to cut general
fund spending on parks by 40%. No, all that is happening for reasons
those politicians don’t want to discuss.

The painful truth – the iceberg below the surface – is that stopping
a few spiked salaries will do nothing for government budgets and even
less for our massive retirement debts to government employees because
the real culprits are the excessive growth of employment costs and decades of unfunded retirement promises to government employees.

At the state level, more than 50% of the increase in state revenue this
year when compared to state revenue ten years ago will be spent on
increases in employee compensation and benefits, which grew at twice
the rate of inflation (even after netting out growth in headcount,
which actually grew slower than population).

 Retirement benefit costs
alone are doubling in size every 4.5 years, and they will keep doubling
at that rate or faster because the state has accumulated more than $500
billion of pension debt and $100 billion of retiree healthcare debt.
Those retirement promises are contractual and thus, unlike even Social Security and Medicare, that debt is binding.

All of this could have been avoided in the past if politicians had not
excessively increased salaries and not passed unfunded increases in
retirement benefits. But we can’t change the past. So what we need now
isn’t grandstanding, but rather honesty and real reform.

The truth is that all we can do now is stop that debt from growing (by
reducing retirement promises to new employees and requiring honest
accounting and funding of those promises as they’re made) and mitigate
the consequences of past excesses (by requiring larger pension
contributions and other concessions from existing and future
employees). But these politicians would rather rail against Bell for
the cameras than actually address the problem.

Worse, they have allowed the iceberg to grow. For years the Governor
has asked the legislature to stop pension debt from growing by
repealing SB 400, the bill they passed in 1999 that boosted unfunded
pension promises. Every day that SB 400 is in effect is a day that adds
to pension debt. Moreover, legislators know that SB 400 was passed in
error. In fact, members of the current legislature who voted for it
have said that had they known of the risks to the budget from passing
that bill, they wouldn’t have voted for it.

they still refuse to repeal SB 400. Why? Because the government
employee unions they depend on to win elections have told them they
must get something in exchange. In fact, those politicians faithfully
recite the union shibboleth that SB 400 must be collectively bargained
when the truth is that the pension increase granted by SB 400 was
enacted statutorily in large part because the unions at that time
wanted to take the pension issue out of collective bargaining. Lewis
Carroll himself couldn’t have written a more upside-down story.

So don’t be distracted by all the grandstanding. Instead, demand action
on the real problem. By tomorrow the legislature could repeal SB 400,
demand transparent accounting from state pension funds, and require
larger pension contributions from government employees. Now those would
be great headlines.

Comment on this article

Please note, statements and opinions expressed on the Fox&Hounds Blog are solely those of their respective authors and may not represent the views of Fox&Hounds Daily or its employees thereof. Fox&Hounds Daily is not responsible for the accuracy of any of the information supplied by the site's bloggers.