Department of Hypocrisy: California Republicans, Champions Of Direct Democracy, Now Want To Violate It

Joe Mathews's picture
Journalist and Irvine senior fellow at the New America Foundation

Today's LA Times story by my longtime colleague Evan Halper makes one thing painfully clear. California's Republican legislative leaders, for all their championing of direct democracy and the rule of the people when it comes to subjects such as Prop 13 (property taxes) and Prop 22 (same-sex marriage ban), are prepared to violate all sorts of voter-approved initiatives to get a budget deal and avoid a tax increase.

Halper got his hands on a memo that details what Republicans are talking about. As Halper recounts the memo's contents, the Republican proposals involve "diverting money specifically set aside by voters for local governments, road and other transportation projects, mental health programs and early childhood education." To give a little history, voters set aside money for transportation via ballot initiative with Prop 42 (2002), for local government with Prop 1A (2004), mental health programs with Prop 63 (2004), and early childhood with Prop 10 (1998).

For Republicans to want to raid such funds is hypocrisy. To borrow against such funds in the name of opposing tax increases is dishonest. The act of raiding such funds creates a debt for the state that must be paid back. The very act of raiding the funds is thus a tax increase in disguise.

While much of Halper's story is about the sales tax, the dispute between Republican Assembly leader Mike Villines and Gov. Schwarzenegger is not merely a fight over taxes, no matter how much conservatives frame it as such. It's also about the merits of raiding such funds and violating the will of voters. Schwarzenegger is saying that you can hold the line on all tax cuts or protect the will of the voters -- but you can't do both. And he thinks there's a deal in which he trades a temporary sales tax hike for a rainy day fund and some sort of spending limit.

If he's right, Republicans should leap at the deal -- and focus their attention on making sure that the spending limit is real. Republicans also should bargain for a seat at the table in the tax reform effort being launched by Assembly Speaker Karen Bass. And when they get such a seat, they need to participate openly, with the knowledge that some taxes may go up and some may go down as a result.

Yes, that may be too much to hope for. But Republicans could bring a business perspective to tax reform, and focus the reform effort not only on producing a broader, more stable tax base but a tax approach that improves the growth picture in California.

Memo

This is the quote from the Times article identifying the source of the memo. "But a memo obtained by The Times that was drafted by local government and transportation lobbyists close to the negotiations spells out what is on the table." Clearly this is not a memo written by Mike Villines, but people who believe they know what Mike is thinking. Your introduction to the article is disingenuous. On the other hand, if local government lobbyists are suggesting borrowing from the local government, I would sure like to see the memo. Bob Whalen Mayor, City of Clovis

Smokin Joe

Yo - What are you smokin Joe? If you really had a copy of such a document I'm thinking you would have made it public. I'm guessing that you have fallen for a classic mis-information tactic used by those who want to devide the GOP and help the left wingers continue with the Big Spending.

Department of Hypocrisy

What really has to happen it for the Democrats to finally cut their spending. There is so much waste that the public is having cover. The Mayor's trips out of the country (?), expensive automobiles for our elected officals. Free everything for people that are here illegally, etc. etc. Edison and DWP have huge profits and their CEO have been getting fat salaries on the backs of the rate holders. This is not a time to raise taxes, this is a time to cut spending. The average person has had to do that and so should our California government!!!

Mike Villines

I know Mike Villines, and you don't have any idea what you are talking about.

Please note, statements and opinions expressed on the Fox&Hounds Blog are solely those of their respective authors and may not represent the views of Fox&Hounds Daily or its employees thereof. Fox&Hounds Daily is not responsible for the accuracy of any of the information supplied by the site's bloggers.